Secret Candle List – Pick a Scent | Discontinued & Retired Scents at a Discount | White Elephant Gift

Welcome to the Secret List 🤫🕯️

These are the scents that didn’t make it to the main shelf. Some are retired favorites, some were limited runs, and some are one-of-a-kind pours from years past. They’re all still beautifully made and hand-poured with the same care as everything else in the shop. They’re just priced to find a new home.

Once they’re gone, they’re gone for good.

Perfect for:

• White elephant and Yankee swap gifts (everyone fights over the candle)
• Stocking stuffers and teacher gifts
• Coworker, neighbor, and “just because” gifts
• Treating yourself to an old favorite before it disappears

1. Coastal Drift – Fresh sea mist and salty ocean air
2. The Secret Garden – Soft, blooming garden lilac
3. Bubble Milk Tea – Creamy milk tea with a sweet, sugary finish
4. Watermelon Sugar – Juicy watermelon with a sugary twist
5. The Tea Room – Classic Earl Grey with bright bergamot
6. Banana Bread Baddie – Warm, fresh-baked banana bread
7. Grandma’s Southern Puddin’ – Banana pudding, vanilla wafers and all
8. Redwood Forest – Towering woods, earthy and grounding
9. Bella’s Strawberry Patch – Sweet, sun-ripened strawberries
10. Matcha Latte – Smooth matcha green tea with creamy milk
11. Cup of Lukes – A fresh-poured cup of diner coffee
12. Star Hollow Mornings – Cozy small-town mornings with coffee and something sweet from the bakery
13. Buttered Toast – Warm, golden toast with melting butter
14. Bacon, Please – Yes, really. Smoky, savory bacon (the ultimate white elephant pick)
15. Mudroom – Earthy, lived-in, and cozy, like coming in from the cold
16. Misty Peaks – Crisp, cool mountain mist
17. Little Light – Soft, clean baby powder
18. French Madeleine – Buttery French tea cakes with a hint of vanilla
19. Dreamsicle – Orange and vanilla cream, just like the ice cream bar
20. Teddy Grahams – Honey graham crackers, sweet and nostalgic
21. Lemon Pound Cake – Zesty lemon glaze over rich buttery cake